The same bottle, a different closure
On this page10
Two shelves that nearly coincide
The thin oil shelf is 78 glass containers; the high alcohol shelf is 81. Both are led by Boston rounds at 48. The windows overlap across most of their range and both exclude plastic.
Which is not a fault in the data
It is what the materials require. A thin oil in glass and a high alcohol liquid in glass are the same packaging problem at the level of the container, and they stop being the same problem at the neck.
The oil takes a dropper
40 dropper assemblies sit on this shelf. A dropper is dose control and a ritual, and for beard oil it is close to a category expectation rather than an option.
The aftershave takes a sprayer
18 fine mist sprayers, mostly 24-410 and 20-410. An even application across a face, far less product used per application, and no splash.
Which is the useful lesson
In this craft the closure carries more of the product decision than the bottle does. A buyer choosing a container first and a closure afterwards has the order backwards for half of this range.
So specify the neck first
Decide the dispensing method, take the neck finish it needs, then choose among the containers that carry it. 24-410 appears 42 times on this shelf and 20-400 at 70, so both dropper and sprayer routes have real depth behind them.
And it protects you later
A container on a well populated finish can change closure without changing bottle. A container on a finish with two options cannot, and that only becomes visible when you want to change something.
The same logic runs through the rest of the range
A beard butter and a shave soap are both wide mouth jars and they are not the same product, because one is scooped with a finger and the other is loaded with a wet brush. Container families repeat across this craft far more than the products do, and the differences keep landing on the opening rather than on the vessel.
Which is why the shelf carries more closures than containers
527 closures against 358 containers. That ratio is the shape of the craft: a modest number of glass and plastic bodies, and a wide choice of what to put on top of them. Shopping it the other way round throws most of the available difference away.