Buy a full case and the price per unit drops automaticallyRequest a sample
AccountCart0
All ContainersBottlesJarsCaps & ClosuresPumps & SprayersTubs & PailsJugsDroppersTinsTubesAccessories
Industries
Learn
What goes wrong

A bigger bottle crossed a line

Updated

On this page9
Nothing about the formula changed. The bottle got bigger.

How it happens

A glue remover sells well in a small bottle, a customer asks for better value, and a larger size is added. The acetonitrile trigger is more than 500 mg in a single container, so the larger size can be over the line while the smaller one is under it.

Which is counterintuitive

Almost every other threshold in this library is a percentage, and a percentage does not move when the bottle does. A mass per container is the exception and it catches people exactly because of that.

The same product, two answers

So a range can have one size requiring special packaging and another not, which is correct and looks like an inconsistency. Treating the range as one regulatory object is the mistake.

And nobody recomputes on a size extension

A new size feels like a packaging decision, not a formula change, so the compliance file is not reopened. That is the specific organizational failure this paragraph produces.

Methacrylic acid does not behave this way

It is a percentage, weight to volume, in a single retail package, so the bottle size does not change it. Knowing which of your triggers is a mass and which is a concentration is the useful distinction.

Shrinking the bottle is a legitimate answer

Where a mass threshold is the problem, fill volume is a lever. That is worth considering alongside child-resistant packaging rather than treating the packaging as the only option.

Recompute per size, and date it

Concentration times fill volume, for every size, written down. It is one line of arithmetic and it is the whole control.

Know which of your triggers move with the bottle

Mass-per-container triggers move; percentage triggers do not. Writing that distinction at the top of the compliance file is a one- line control that prevents the whole failure.

References

16 CFR 1700.14(a)(18), Glue removers containing acetonitrile: household glue removers in a liquid form containing more than 500 mg of acetonitrile in a single container. law.cornell.edu
16 CFR 1700.14(a)(29), Methacrylic acid. Liquid household products containing more than 5 percent methacrylic acid by weight to volume in a single retail package require special packaging, except products applied by an absorbent material contained inside a dispenser such as a pen-like marker, provided no free liquid is within the device and the acid will emerge only through the tip under any reasonably foreseeable conditions of use. law.cornell.edu
Written from federal regulation and from measured catalog data, not from a salon. Whether a formula crosses 5 percent methacrylic acid or 500 mg of acetonitrile is a question about your formula and your container size, and the percentages here are the test rather than the answer. Nothing on these pages certifies a package as child-resistant.