The check, before the formula is locked
Updated
On this page9
One: cosmetic or drug?
Does the product reduce the production of perspiration, and will anything you publish say so? Either one puts you in the antiperspirant monograph. Addressing odor, and claiming only that, keeps it a cosmetic.
Two: if a drug, is the active on the list and under its ceiling?
Checked on an anhydrous basis, excluding buffer components, against the enumerated maximum for that compound and that dosage form, and meeting the USP-NF atomic ratios where they apply. Get the raw material specification from the supplier.
Three: which claims can you actually prove?
The base Uses phrase needs no testing. "Lasts 24 hours" and the other duration claims need 20 percent sweat reduction demonstrated over 24 hours; "extra effective" needs 30 percent. Decide this before artwork.
Four: is every required statement present and verbatim?
The antiperspirant identity, the Uses phrase from the menu, the three standard warnings including the kidney disease one, the two extra aerosol warnings if applicable, and "apply to underarms only", all in the Drug Facts format.
Five: will it fit on the container you want?
A Drug Facts panel on a 59 mL jar or a 65 mL tube is tight. Work the label out against the actual container before committing to tooling, artwork or a case quantity.
And for the stick, test the mechanism
Filled with your real base, in the real tube, twisted repeatedly, left hot and left cold over weeks. Binding and slumping are mechanical failures that only appear in use.
File the five answers with the formula
Classification, active and calculated percentage, test data, label version and container. A reformulation can move the classification itself, and then all five need rechecking rather than one.
Most of this is decided in words, not chemistry
Four of the five questions are about classification, claims and label text, and only one is about the formula. That is the shape of this category, and it is why the expensive mistakes here are made by marketing rather than by the bench.