It stayed tacky
Updated
On this page8
Tacky everywhere means the ratio
Uniform softness across the whole piece points at the proportions. Check whether the product specifies weight or volume and whether you used that one, because measuring a volume-ratio product by weight gives a confident wrong answer.
Tacky in patches means the mixing
Soft areas next to properly cured ones mean the proportions were right overall and wrong locally. The usual cause is unmixed material from the sides and bottom of the cup going into the mold. Scraping thoroughly and decanting into a second cup fixes it.
Tacky only at the surface
Often a cold or humid cure, and with some systems moisture at the surface during cure produces a greasy film. It can also be inhibition if something the resin touched interfered with it, which is the silicone failure arriving in a different material.
It does not fix itself
Extra time does not complete a reaction that has no partner left to react with. Waiting a week on an off-ratio piece achieves nothing, which is hard to accept and is the truth.
What to do with it
Usually scrap. A thin tacky layer can sometimes be removed and the piece recoated with a correctly measured batch, but a through-soft casting is finished. Do not sell it: uncured material at the surface is sensitizing material somebody else will handle.
Record the batch
Ratio method, the room temperature and which cup. Three columns, and they turn a recurring mystery into a pattern you can see.
Do not sand it to see if it is better underneath
Sanding uncured resin makes dust carrying reactive material and spreads the exposure rather than removing the problem. If the surface is tacky, the thing to do is work out why, not abrade it.